2022
W-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin
L- San Diego Padres- Adam Noga

2021
W-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin
L- San Diego Padres- Adam Noga

2020
W-Montreal Expos- Brandon Harris
L- St. Louis Cardinals- Devin Cunningham

2019
W-Oakland Athletics- Ryan Bolin
L- Miami Marlins- Dave Jones

2018
W-Montreal Expos- Brandon Harris
L- Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin

2017
W-St. Louis Cardinals- Devin Cunningham
L- Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin

2016
W-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin
L- Miami Marlins- Dave Jones

2015
W-Pittsburgh Pirates- Doug Benzel
L- Tampa Bay Rays- Brian Bolin

2014
W-Atlanta Braves- Tony Hopkins
L- Miami Marlins- Dave Jones

2013
W-Atlanta Braves- Tony Hopkins
L-St. Louis Cardinals- Devin Cunningham

2012
W-St. Louis Cardinals- Devin Cunningham
L-Atlanta Braves- Tony Hopkins

2011
W-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones
L-Los Angeles Dodgers- Rich Kammer

2010
W-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones
L-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin

2009
W-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones
L-St. Louis Cardinals- Devin Cunningham

2008
W-Atlanta Braves- Tony Hopkins
L-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones

2007
W-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones
L-Seattle Mariners- Ryan Sopko

2006
W-Seattle Mariners- Ryan Sopko
L-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin

2005
W-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones
L-New York Yankees- Rick DiMichele

2004
W-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones
L-Texas Rangers- Bob Bolin

2003
W-Seattle Mariners- Ryan Sopko
L-Florida Marlins- Dave Jones

2002
W-Atlanta Braves- Brandon Sopko
L-Miwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin

2001
W-Atlanta Braves- Brandon Sopko
L-Seattle Mariners- Ryan Sopko

2000
W-Tampa Bay Devil Rays- Brian Bolin
L-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin

1999
W-Toronto Blue Jays- Bridget Bolin
L-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin

1998
W-Milwaukee Brewers- Bobby Bolin
L-Texas Rangers- Bob Bolin

1997
W-Seattle Mariners- Brian Bolin
L-Texas Rangers- Bob Bolin